Eagle is the second player elected into the Senior section of the PBA Hall of Fame, following John Handegard, who was inducted in 2009. Has 12 career Senior Tour titles which ranks tied for second all-time. Among his titles are four Senior majors – Reno PBA Senior World Invitational (1997); The Villages Senior World Championship (1999); PBA Senior National Championship (2001), and USBC Senior Masters (2003). He was the PBA Senior Rookie of the Year in 1996 and Senior Player of the Year in 1999. In 171 PBA Senior Tour tournaments he has finished in the top five 40 times. He also won 10 Senior Regional titles and three PBA Tour titles. Has won PBA titles in five different decades.